Every Greek household makes both at Christmas, though the proportions vary by family tradition and argument. Some families are kourabiedes families; others are melomakarona families; most make large quantities of both and argue about which is better. The debate is genuinely regional: kourabiedes have stronger roots in northern Greece and Macedonia; melomakarona are associated more with Athens and the Peloponnese, where olive oil is the cooking fat of choice. The olive oil in melomakarona is not a substitution for butter — it is the defining ingredient that gives these cookies their specific character.
The honey soaking is done hot-to-hot: the cookies come out of the oven golden and still hot, and they are immediately dipped (or submerged) in warm — not cold — honey syrup. The warmth of both the cookie and the syrup allows maximum absorption. Cookies left to cool before soaking absorb far less honey and remain drier and less fragrant. The cookies should be slightly wet with honey when finished.
The Olive Oil Dough
Olive oil: The full fat component is olive oil — no butter. This produces a different texture from shortbread: more tender but less crumbly; the fat is more liquid and integrated into the dough differently than solid butter.
The emulsion: Some recipes add a small amount of orange juice and/or cognac/brandy to the oil — these create a light emulsion that distributes the oil throughout the dough more evenly and adds flavor.
The flour: A combination of all-purpose flour and semolina in some recipes — the semolina adds a slight grainy texture that contrasts nicely with the honey-softened exterior.
Baking soda: Creates very slight leavening — melomakarona should have a slightly open crumb to absorb the honey, not be completely dense.
The Spice Profile
The combination that makes melomakarona immediately recognizable:
- Orange: Both zest and juice — generously used. The citrus is the dominant flavor.
- Cinnamon: Ground; a significant amount.
- Cloves: Ground; less than cinnamon but present and important.
- Brandy or Metaxa: A small amount added to the liquid; adds warmth and depth.
The Honey Syrup Soaking
The syrup: Water + honey + sugar + a cinnamon stick + a strip of orange peel, simmered briefly. The water dilutes the honey slightly so it flows into the cookie more easily; the sugar stabilizes it.
The temperature: The syrup should be warm — not boiling, not cold. Hot enough to remain fluid.
The cookie temperature: The cookies must also be hot when dipped — they should go directly from the oven tray into the syrup.
The soaking: Each cookie is submerged or turned in the syrup for 15–20 seconds — enough for the cookie to absorb honey but not so long it becomes sodden.
The walnut coating: After soaking, the cookie is immediately rolled in finely crushed walnuts (pulsed briefly in a food processor — not a fine meal, but small irregular pieces). The honey surface makes the walnuts adhere.
The Complete Recipe
Makes: approximately 40 cookies | Time: 1.5 hours
Cookie Dough
- 200ml light olive oil
- 100g sugar
- 100ml orange juice
- Zest of 1 large orange
- 50ml brandy or Metaxa
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- 1 teaspoon cinnamon
- ½ teaspoon ground cloves
- 450g all-purpose flour
- 1 teaspoon baking soda
- ½ teaspoon baking powder
Honey Syrup
- 200ml water
- 250g sugar
- 250g honey (thyme honey preferred)
- 1 cinnamon stick
- Zest of ½ orange
Walnut Coating
- 150g walnuts, pulsed to coarse crumbs
Method
1. Make the dough: Whisk olive oil and sugar until combined. Add orange juice, zest, brandy, vanilla, cinnamon, and cloves; whisk smooth. Mix flour, baking soda, and baking powder; gradually add to wet mixture until a soft, non-sticky dough forms. If sticky, add flour a tablespoon at a time. Do not overwork.
2. Shape: Take tablespoon-sized pieces; roll into oval shapes (4–5cm long). Place on lined baking sheets; make light hatching marks on the top with a fork.
3. Bake: Bake at 180°C for 20–22 minutes until golden-brown. Do not overbake — they should be just cooked through.
4. Make syrup: While cookies bake, combine water, sugar, honey, cinnamon stick, and orange zest; bring to a boil; simmer 5 minutes. Keep warm.
5. Soak while hot: As soon as cookies come out of the oven, begin soaking in batches. Dip each cookie in warm honey syrup for 15–20 seconds per side; remove with a slotted spoon.
6. Coat with walnuts: Immediately roll each soaked cookie in crushed walnuts. Place on a rack to cool.
Store: At room temperature, covered, for up to 2 weeks. The cookies absorb moisture from the honey over time and become more tender.
Related reading: Kourabiedes Greek Almond Shortbread Guide | Baklava Turkish Greek Pistachio Walnut Guide | Pastéis de Nata Portuguese Custard Tart Guide
The full recipes live in the book.
Get Tokyo Meets Tuscany on AmazonPaperback $24.99 · Hardcover $34.99 · eBook $9.99